STIPENDIARY MAGISTRATE'S COURT.
Victoria, October 14th, 1858.
J. M'Leod, Esq., presiding.
Antonio Fernandes, of Golden Grove, was charged by James M'Donagh, Esq., of Belfield, with having on or about the 26th September last stolen an Ox. Sancho, a Creole labourer belonging to Golden Grove, Georgetown, was charged with having received the said Ox, knowing it to be stolen.
Jonathan Hodge, a constable in the Georgetown market, deposed that on the 1st instant he saw the prisoner Sancho offer the hide of an ox for sale in the Georgetown market. That he went with him to see the beef, which was hanging up on a stall, and on the following Monday James Shipley said that the hide belonged to an ox which he had recently bought. Mr. C. Witness told Shipley to be cautious for fear of making a mistake, as Mr. Lynex might have other oxen of the same brand, and he Shipley had slaughtered several; after this, Shipley took the hide to look at it more carefully, and on returning to him to detain the ox, as it had his brand, a cross surrounded by a circle, and he took the hide over to the Clerk of the Market, and the ox was detained.
James Shipley proved that the hide came off an ox which he had purchased from Mr. Cox of Pln. Hope, and a receipt was also exhibited to complainant, Mr. Lynex, of 5 oxen which he had purchased from him, and Shipley also proved that the ox in question had no other brand than M. C.. It was usual for butchers to brand oxen purchased at sales, but that formality was sometimes dispensed with when the ox was slaughtered without a new brand.
John G. Coelho, who was in the employ of James Shipley, deposed that on the 1st instant Mr. Coelho was with an ox in the market branded M. C.. Witness asked him where he got it, as he knew no other cattle had gone astray, and requested him if he could make it out, to call at his store, as he would try to make let him know. Witness then held complainant of the car that Coelho had brought to the market. Witness is frequently in the habit of killing cattle branded M. C.. Whatever cattle is purchased from Craigmill is sent to Shipley, witness gets them from pln. Enfield on the instructions of plaintiff; no other brand is put on them as they are to be slaughtered immediately. It is only customary to re-mark cattle when they are purchased for keeping.
Thomas Verfstein deposed that he had bought several cargoes of cattle for complainant, and had them branded M. C. under his inspection, and that they were pastured at pln. Belfield. On the 25th September witness received information from complainant that one of his oxen had been offered for sale in the market and requested to see it. Witness examined the beef and hide, and recognized the hide as one of the M. C. cattle. Witness, on coming from the market, witness met Coelho, who informed him that the ox had been brought from a place up the country, but declined naming the person, or saying who the ox belonged to. On the 27th September, witness called on Mr. Coelho at his shop, and informed him that complainant had determined to have the matter investigated before the Magistrate, as he was determined to put a stop to the loss of property. He then said that a man named Manuel Fernandes had sent him the ox for sale, and that he would get the person who brought it down.
Antonio Fernandes stated in his defence, that he had purchased the ox from Mr. Cox, at Belfield, on the 31st May. That Mr. Cox of pln. Haslinton, had given him an order on Mr. Georgeback for 30 dolls., for the purchase of the ox, and exhibited the order for 30 dolls., signed John Cox. Prisoner also stated that he had put the ox to run on the range of the ox at pln. Golden Grove, and called for his witness.
Mr. Cox of pln. Haslinton, who stated that he had purchased the ox at an execution sale at Belfield. That on the following day Mr. Georgeback called upon him to purchase the ox, and stated that he had sold some cattle the day before and was disappointed in getting the money, but he told him to take the ox, and if he paid he might become his security the cattle were then taken over to Haslinton, and a order for 30 dollars was given by Mr. Georgeback to take place on 31st May at Belfield. When the 31st May arrived he had the oxen re-sold, as Josiah could not pay for them. The ox in question was not among those re-sold, as only Mr. Sancho's and Mr. Louis Fernandes's were among the lot, on account of his being from home and not having the money with him to pay for it. After this, Mr. Cox stated he came down to town, when Fernandes called upon him to pay for the ox, and witness gave him the receipt which was produced in court. Upon receipt of the money, witness Fernandes one of his draft Oxen and his ox was re-sold. Witness sent the ox from Haslinton to be sent to Belfield. Witness then received a note from Mr. Lynex that the ox was claimed, and that the case was to be investigated before the Magistrate on the following day, and he accordingly came up to give his evidence.
Cheeswright Josiah deposed that he was at the sale of the oxen at Belfield when Mr. Cox bought the claimed ox. That the ox now detained in the market is the same ox. Witness was this day at the slaughter house with Fernandes, and identified the ox as being the same ox. The ox at Belfield was one of those purchased by him on the 1st March, and sold by the Marshal. These cattle were all branded M. C.. Witness examined the one in question, and it had the M. C. brand. It was the same identical ox that Fernandes purchased on 31st May.
William Gordon, constable, corroborated the above; he was present when the last witness went to the slaughter house and saw him point out the ox in the presence of Fernandes.
The Magistrate then stated that he remembered that Fernandes purchased an ox at pln. Belfield on 31st May, and that he was the owner of the ox. That on 21st May, on his way up the coast, about two or three weeks ago, it was yoked with one of Mr. Cox's oxen, when he passed through Haslinton, and witness did not see it after it was sent to town.
Mr. Lynch stated that the ox had been a yearling purchased an ox at Belfield sometime ago. Witness recollected seeing this identical one about Belfield ox about three weeks ago, and wanted to put it in the pound, when he was told it was Fernandes's.
The Magistrate said that there could be no doubt that the ox in question was the property of Antonio Fernandes, and that it was a pity that much trouble and inconvenience might have been saved if Antonio had at once accompanied Mr. Coelho to prove his possession of the ox. He therefore dismissed the case.—Communicated.
No comments:
Post a Comment